T
TubeFolio
Back to Dashboard

When To Buy Mosaic Stock? NYSE: MOS

Summary

Sven provides a comprehensive analysis of Mosaic (MOS), highlighting its current struggles within the potash and phosphate sectors. Sven argues that the company is currently burning approximately $500 million in cash annually due to geopolitical factors driving up the prices of sulfur and ammonia, making phosphate production unprofitable. However, Sven states that this situation is unsustainable because soil nutrient depletion will eventually force farmers to increase fertilizer application, creating pent-up demand.

Sven emphasizes the massive valuation gap, noting that Mosaic's Esterhazy mine alone could be worth $10 billion—double the company's current market capitalization minus debt. Sven also points to a $2 billion stake in the Saudi company Ma'aden that will become liquid between 2027 and 2029. Sven warns of risks such as BHP’s Jansen project, which will add significant potash supply to the market, but remains optimistic about Mosaic's long-term recovery potential. Sven suggests a potential entry strategy involving a small initial position of 1-2%, with the intention to add more if the market cap falls further toward the $3-4 billion range, which Sven defines as a "real bargain" yielding 15-20% in mid-cycle conditions.

**Mosaic (MOS):** Sven views the stock as a volatile but attractive cyclical play currently trading at a deep discount to its asset value. Sven states that the company is burning cash due to high sulfur costs but expects a significant rebound when demand for phosphates returns. Sven suggests that if the price drops further to a market cap of $3-4 billion, it would represent a massive buying opportunity.
**Nutrien (NTR):** Sven compares Mosaic to Nutrien, noting that Nutrien is the more stable and less volatile investment in the sector. Sven previously held Nutrien and found it to be a more consistent performer, although it did not see the same 600% explosive growth that Mosaic experienced during the 2020-2022 period. Sven regards Nutrien as a benchmark for stability against Mosaic's high volatility.
**BHP (BHP):** Sven identifies BHP as a long-term competitive threat to Mosaic's potash business due to the Jansen project. Sven explains that this project will eventually add 8 million tons of potash to the global market, potentially pressuring prices. Sven notes that Phase One of this project is expected to launch next year, followed by Phase Two in 2031.

Mentioned Stocks

NTR
Sentiment: HOLD

Reasoning: Sven mentions Nutrien as a more stable peer in the fertilizer industry that Sven has previously owned. Sven notes that while it is more stable than Mosaic, Sven is currently focusing the analysis on the opportunistic upside of the more volatile Mosaic.

Loading chart...
MOS
Sentiment: BUYAction: RECOMMENDED

Reasoning: Sven argues that Mosaic is undervalued based on its assets, specifically the Esterhazy mine which Sven values at $10 billion. Sven states that the current cash burn is a temporary cyclical issue and that a market capitalization of $3-$4 billion would be a 'real bargain' for long-term investors. Sven is considering buying a 1-2% position within the next 72 hours.

Loading chart...
BHP
Sentiment: HOLD

Reasoning: Sven identifies BHP as a strategic risk to the potash market due to its massive Jansen project which will increase global supply. Sven states that this supply increase starting next year could pressure the margins of incumbents like Mosaic.

Loading chart...