The S&P 500 Is Hiding a Very Different Stock Market
Summary
Nolan explains the growing divergence between the market-capitalization-weighted S&P 500 and the performance of the average stock within the index. Nolan notes that current concentration levels are the highest since the dot-com era, with the top 10 stocks now accounting for nearly 38% of the total index value. Nolan argues that while the standard index effectively reflects the success of giant companies, the standard index can mislead investors about the overall health of the broader market.
Nolan advises against abandoning diversified portfolios simply because those portfolios might lag behind mega-cap-heavy indices in the short term. Nolan states that diversification is a long-term risk management strategy and warns that switching to whatever is currently outperforming often leads to the mistake of buying high and selling low. Nolan emphasizes evaluating portfolios over multi-year periods rather than months.
Nolan introduces a '30-second check' for portfolio health to help investors understand their true exposure. Nolan suggests multiplying the percentage of the top 10 holdings by the total weight of that specific fund in the portfolio to reveal the actual concentration. Nolan also recommends using visualization tools to identify redundancy between popular ETFs that may share many of the same underlying holdings.
Mentioned Stocks
Reasoning: Nolan states the S&P 500 remains a fundamental pillar of Nolan's portfolio despite high concentration. Nolan believes the index accurately reflects the growth of the largest US companies and indicates no intention of moving away from this market-cap-weighted benchmark.
Reasoning: Nolan states that SCHD has very little overlap with tech-heavy funds like QQQM or VGT. Nolan argues this makes SCHD a strong diversification tool to balance out mega-cap concentration and recommends it as a complement to growth-oriented ETFs.
Reasoning: Nolan argues that QQQM, alongside VGT and VUG, exhibits high redundancy and overlap. Nolan points out that these ETFs often hold the same top stocks like Microsoft and Nvidia, stating this can lead to unintentional over-concentration in a few names rather than true diversification.