S&P 500 True Accounting Earnings - Don't Be Fooled!
Summary
Sven provides a critical analysis of the upcoming earnings season, noting that the projected 29% growth for the S&P 500 is heavily distorted by AI spending. He explains a fundamental accounting mismatch: when a company like SpaceX or a Big Tech 'hyperscaler' buys billions in chips from Nvidia, Nvidia records the revenue and high margins immediately. However, the buyer does not record the cost immediately; instead, they capitalize the purchase and depreciate it over 5 to 6 years, often starting only when the chips are fully operational. This results in an immediate boost to aggregate S&P 500 profits while the offsetting costs are delayed for years.
Sven warns that the market is currently in an 'AI bubble' characterized by extreme euphoria and rising valuations. He points out that the Shiller P/E ratio is currently around 40, a level only seen during the Dotcom bubble, which is significantly higher than historical peaks like the Nifty Fifty or the 1920s. He highlights that while accounting earnings look great, the actual cash flows of major tech spenders are turning negative. Sven concludes that if AI demand merely stagnates rather than continues to grow exponentially, the mounting depreciation and interest costs will lead to a severe earnings recession and a massive valuation contraction.
Mentioned Stocks
Reasoning: Sven mentions Micron in the context of companies whose growth rates are currently inflating the S&P 500. He views the entire sector's growth as being driven by the same accounting-led AI bubble he is avoiding.
Reasoning: Sven points out that Nvidia's massive 62% profit margins on chip sales are immediately recognized, while the buyer's costs are deferred via long-term depreciation. He argues this creates a fake earnings boost for the S&P 500 and that the stock is part of an unsustainable AI bubble. He states he is not invested in this bubble.
Reasoning: Sven includes Microsoft among the hyperscalers whose heavy spending fuels current market optimism but hides future costs. He argues that the interest and depreciation expenses tied to these multibillion-dollar investments will eventually materialize and potentially cause a significant drop in valuation, similar to the 2000 market crash.
Reasoning: Sven notes that Google uses a 6-year depreciation schedule for hardware, delaying the accounting impact of its massive AI capital expenditures. He highlights that their cash flows are turning negative and warns that without high returns on these investments, future depreciation and interest will lead to an earnings crash.