Jeremy Grantham vs. Joseph Carlson & CNBC Discussing Crash & Investing! My Take! AMAZING CONTENT!

Value Investing with Sven Carlin, Ph.D.•Jul 25, 2026

Summary

Sven examines the ideological conflict between bearish value investors like Jeremy Grantham and bullish proponents of dollar-cost averaging. Sven argues that the market is currently in a 'two sigma' bubble, making it the most expensive in American history according to the Buffett indicator and P/E ratios. Sven warns that while passive indexing has been successful for the last 15 years, history shows several periods of 17 to 25 years where the market delivered 0% real returns. Sven emphasizes that value investing is fundamentally about not losing money and maintaining a strategy that works regardless of market volatility.

Sven mentions the following specific assets and market segments:

S&P 500 (SPY): Sven argues that the US stock market is currently in a dangerous bubble and is the most expensive in American history. He warns that historical precedents suggest the possibility of a 70% to 80% decline when such valuation extremes eventually revert to the mean. Sven highlights that the current dividend yield is at a historical low, which he predicts will limit long-term expected returns to approximately 5% without government intervention.

Microsoft (MSFT): Sven observes that despite a generally bearish outlook on the broad market, Jeremy Grantham's firm GMO maintains a significant position in Microsoft. This illustrates Sven's point that value investing involves selective allocation to high-quality earnings even when skeptical of overall market levels. Sven uses this example to show that professional value managers still find utility in dominant tech businesses that provide consistent cash flows.

Apple (AAPL): Sven identifies Apple as a core holding in the GMO portfolio, representing about 5.6% of their reported US exposure. He explains that such positions are part of a deliberate strategy focused on business ownership and dividend yields rather than mere price speculation. Sven notes that even those who warn of a market crash often hold these stocks as part of a diversified, earnings-focused mandate.

Regarding price entry points and predictions, Sven mentions that a P/E ratio of 12 and a dividend yield of 4% represent his ideal framework for compounding wealth. He also predicts the possibility of a 70% market decline and suggests that the market could face up to 20 years of zero returns based on historical cycles.

Mentioned Stocks

MSFT

Sentiment: HOLD

Reasoning: Sven mentions Microsoft as a significant holding in Jeremy Grantham's GMO portfolio to demonstrate that value investors still own quality businesses. He explains that even during bubbles, professional managers hold companies with strong earnings and dividends. Sven uses this to contrast broad market speculation with the ownership of specific, cash-generating assets.

Loading chart...

AAPL

Sentiment: HOLD

Reasoning: Sven highlights Apple as a top position within the GMO fund to illustrate that value investing is about portfolio strategy rather than just avoiding the US market. He notes that the focus is on buying yield and earnings growth at a fair price. Sven argues that holding such stocks is consistent with a strategy designed to survive long periods of market stagnation.

Loading chart...

SPY

Sentiment: SELL

Reasoning: Sven labels the current market as a 'two sigma' bubble and the most expensive in American history. He cites historically low dividend yields and high P/E ratios as indicators of extreme risk. Sven warns that a 70% to 80% decline is possible, suggesting that passive indexing at these levels is more akin to gambling than strategic investing.

Loading chart...